DropBox
Original Post
Off topic, but I've seen several mentions of DropBox including links for any forum member to have a look at something, like a photo or file.
I have two portable computers: Toshiba Portege M700 and Toshiba NB305 netbook. I want to keep these in synch (I don't have a NAS or file server in my home office yet, and do not often have access to the local LAN at a client's location). Both computers run Windows 7, Ultimate and Professional.
The idea is that when I go to a meeting or travel, the NB305 will be my computer until I get back or to my destination, then I want to synchronise selected folders as well as Outlook and OneNote. I see synchronising (via USB cable, wifi or Bluetooth) at regular intervals eg 15 minutes, then doing a quick synch just before I leave with the NB305 and again when I get back
BTW, I do take a backup onto an external HDD, but I want to have key folders always in synch and without having to drag and drop, which is one option.
Any comments on using DropBox?
I have two portable computers: Toshiba Portege M700 and Toshiba NB305 netbook. I want to keep these in synch (I don't have a NAS or file server in my home office yet, and do not often have access to the local LAN at a client's location). Both computers run Windows 7, Ultimate and Professional.
The idea is that when I go to a meeting or travel, the NB305 will be my computer until I get back or to my destination, then I want to synchronise selected folders as well as Outlook and OneNote. I see synchronising (via USB cable, wifi or Bluetooth) at regular intervals eg 15 minutes, then doing a quick synch just before I leave with the NB305 and again when I get back
BTW, I do take a backup onto an external HDD, but I want to have key folders always in synch and without having to drag and drop, which is one option.
Any comments on using DropBox?
Reply by Mike
Roger,
DropBox works very well. Basically it sits on a number of computers (and your iPhone if you use one) and syncs the designated folders on each computer to a website. When you log onto each computer it automatically updates to the website. If you are at a completely different computer (or a public one) you can access files from the website. If you have an iPhone you can see them there. It is pretty spiffy.
DropBox works very well. Basically it sits on a number of computers (and your iPhone if you use one) and syncs the designated folders on each computer to a website. When you log onto each computer it automatically updates to the website. If you are at a completely different computer (or a public one) you can access files from the website. If you have an iPhone you can see them there. It is pretty spiffy.
Reply by vegheadjones
I heart dropbox. I use it much the way you plan to Roger and it has made life much easier.
Reply by Mike
Oh, and if you use this link:
https://www.dropbox.com/referrals/NTI1MTk0MDU5
to get your free account, I'll get an extra 250MB of storage space. They have a nice referral program. (I'd not recommend it if I did not use it.)
Ah, one more thing. I have my dropbox set to MyDocuments, which is the default and seemed easiest. I'm working on a OneNote document now and it saves every few seconds. So DropBox is backing up the file all the time. I'm not so sure I want that much of a hit on my processing. I'm not really noticing it but ...
So maybe I'll have OneNote save elsewhere and use something like SyncToy to sync that folder to MyDocuments. Or maybe I'll just accept the hit so that it happens automatically and I won't forget.
https://www.dropbox.com/referrals/NTI1MTk0MDU5
to get your free account, I'll get an extra 250MB of storage space. They have a nice referral program. (I'd not recommend it if I did not use it.)
Ah, one more thing. I have my dropbox set to MyDocuments, which is the default and seemed easiest. I'm working on a OneNote document now and it saves every few seconds. So DropBox is backing up the file all the time. I'm not so sure I want that much of a hit on my processing. I'm not really noticing it but ...
So maybe I'll have OneNote save elsewhere and use something like SyncToy to sync that folder to MyDocuments. Or maybe I'll just accept the hit so that it happens automatically and I won't forget.
Reply by Brian
I just recently switched from Dropbox to Live Mesh from Microsoft. My primary reasons were:
- Live Mesh gives 5GB cloud storage, to Dropbox's 2GB
- Live Mesh has a remote desktop feature
- Live Mesh can sync folders/files between 2 computers only, skipping the cloud (handy to keep your 16GB music collection synced between 2 computers w/o consuming your 5GB web storage)
So I sync my documents between 2 PCs and the cloud, but my MP3s only between the 2 computers.
However, Live Mesh does not do file versioning like Dropbox does, so once you make a change to a file and it syncs to the cloud, that's the only version you have. I have other backup solutions in place to mitigate this risk, though.
Just an alternative to consider. Dropbox is a great service that I happily used until I decided my music collection must follow me wherever I go.
- Live Mesh gives 5GB cloud storage, to Dropbox's 2GB
- Live Mesh has a remote desktop feature
- Live Mesh can sync folders/files between 2 computers only, skipping the cloud (handy to keep your 16GB music collection synced between 2 computers w/o consuming your 5GB web storage)
So I sync my documents between 2 PCs and the cloud, but my MP3s only between the 2 computers.
However, Live Mesh does not do file versioning like Dropbox does, so once you make a change to a file and it syncs to the cloud, that's the only version you have. I have other backup solutions in place to mitigate this risk, though.
Just an alternative to consider. Dropbox is a great service that I happily used until I decided my music collection must follow me wherever I go.
Reply by Brian
Also, I doubt either service would handle Outlook PSTs gracefully. Never tried it though. OneNote works well over cloud syncing as long as you're not editing your Notebooks simultaneously on 2 PCs.
Reply by Mike
Brian,
Thanks for that input. I'll have to give that a try. And yes, I forgot to mention the versions. That is very handy in case you screw up.
Thanks for that input. I'll have to give that a try. And yes, I forgot to mention the versions. That is very handy in case you screw up.
Reply by RogerJ
Thanks everyone, quick responses!
Not sure about Live Mesh, except maybe for music as Brian does.
Mike: why should I not just use SyncToy if I'm only using two "local" computers? I do realise DropBox has other advantages for file sharing.
If I exceed 2 Gb with DropBox, I will end up paying a monthly charge which after about 7 months would be more expensive than ViceVersa, another utility.
Not sure about Live Mesh, except maybe for music as Brian does.
Mike: why should I not just use SyncToy if I'm only using two "local" computers? I do realise DropBox has other advantages for file sharing.
If I exceed 2 Gb with DropBox, I will end up paying a monthly charge which after about 7 months would be more expensive than ViceVersa, another utility.
Reply by Mike
Roger,
That may be the best way for you. The advantage to DropBox is that it is automatic. Your computers remain in sync so long as they are connected to the Internet. Also that you can get to the files from any computer that has access to the Internet.
As to the capacity, yes, SyncToy has no limit. I think DropBox is better for syncing individual files in a designated directory than the whole machine. That is why I am syncing "My Documents". Most programs save there by default (and I check to have them do that). So all of my word processing and spreadsheet files are synced. I'm using a small fraction of my capacity now.
That may be the best way for you. The advantage to DropBox is that it is automatic. Your computers remain in sync so long as they are connected to the Internet. Also that you can get to the files from any computer that has access to the Internet.
As to the capacity, yes, SyncToy has no limit. I think DropBox is better for syncing individual files in a designated directory than the whole machine. That is why I am syncing "My Documents". Most programs save there by default (and I check to have them do that). So all of my word processing and spreadsheet files are synced. I'm using a small fraction of my capacity now.
Reply by kneitinga
The following dropbox help entry could be interesting for you:
What is LAN sync?
LAN sync is a Dropbox feature that speeds syncing dramatically when the file exists on your Local Area Network (LAN).
http://www.dropbox.com/help/137
What is LAN sync?
LAN sync is a Dropbox feature that speeds syncing dramatically when the file exists on your Local Area Network (LAN).
http://www.dropbox.com/help/137
Reply by Roger J
Thanks Mike, and kneitingafor that LAN hint.
This thread has given me impetus to restructure my folder tree structure (note to self: write it down in DWM, New Entry, Today + 28!).
I've always stayed clear of My Documents, preferring to have a "DATA" folder to make quick copying onto my external HDD (but I use Acronis True Image for security backup images). I think initially I will separate DATA into DATA ARCHIVE (stuff up to and including 2008) and DATA CURRENT, the latter to include this year, last year and ongoing folders like my accounting, personal stuff etc.
I also need to rationalise Outlook in a big way, it's getting too big, again.
I think I'll try out DropBox, I like the fact that there is an online copy, just wary when my Internet access is flaky, which it sometimes is at some of my assignment locations.
This thread has given me impetus to restructure my folder tree structure (note to self: write it down in DWM, New Entry, Today + 28!).
I've always stayed clear of My Documents, preferring to have a "DATA" folder to make quick copying onto my external HDD (but I use Acronis True Image for security backup images). I think initially I will separate DATA into DATA ARCHIVE (stuff up to and including 2008) and DATA CURRENT, the latter to include this year, last year and ongoing folders like my accounting, personal stuff etc.
I also need to rationalise Outlook in a big way, it's getting too big, again.
I think I'll try out DropBox, I like the fact that there is an online copy, just wary when my Internet access is flaky, which it sometimes is at some of my assignment locations.
Reply by Mike
Roger,
Yes, weak Internet access could be a problem. OTOH, all you need to is walk into a coffee shop these days, open up your laptop, and zing, you are up to date. It will sync when it can.
Folders: Yes, I used to think My Documents was a pain. Then I realized that it would be just as easy to reorganize that to make it useful. I have subfolders under it sorting things out nicely. But whatever works. Oh, and if I did not make it clear, you don't HAVE to use My Documents. You get to specify a folder. I just use it because it is simpler. Most Windows programs default to saving there so it is less to remember to move around later. I started out using a folder on my desktop that I dragged stuff into. Then it seemed easier to just let things go where Windows wants to put them and be happy with that.
Now I love Big Brother. LOL ;-)
Yes, weak Internet access could be a problem. OTOH, all you need to is walk into a coffee shop these days, open up your laptop, and zing, you are up to date. It will sync when it can.
Folders: Yes, I used to think My Documents was a pain. Then I realized that it would be just as easy to reorganize that to make it useful. I have subfolders under it sorting things out nicely. But whatever works. Oh, and if I did not make it clear, you don't HAVE to use My Documents. You get to specify a folder. I just use it because it is simpler. Most Windows programs default to saving there so it is less to remember to move around later. I started out using a folder on my desktop that I dragged stuff into. Then it seemed easier to just let things go where Windows wants to put them and be happy with that.
Now I love Big Brother. LOL ;-)
Reply by RogerJ
Mike,
Thanks, but in my travels to and from A to Z - Afghanistan to Zambia - I've come across some really flaky connections. Even the "new" mobile broadband service in Zambia last year was unable to facilitate Internet banking, not a zing in sight ;-}
I've been thinking about your My Documents suggestion a bit more, and the changed structure can be nested under My Documents.
The exercise has been worthwhile, my archives are being relocated to my external HDD, plus a few DVDs of the same data to be kept at another address, just in case. Years ago there was an advertising campaign run by one of the magnetic media producers (disks, tapes etc). The message was, "There are two kinds of data: that which is on your hard disk and that which has been backed up, there is no other in-between alternative."
Now back to restructuring my folders . . . .
Thanks, but in my travels to and from A to Z - Afghanistan to Zambia - I've come across some really flaky connections. Even the "new" mobile broadband service in Zambia last year was unable to facilitate Internet banking, not a zing in sight ;-}
I've been thinking about your My Documents suggestion a bit more, and the changed structure can be nested under My Documents.
The exercise has been worthwhile, my archives are being relocated to my external HDD, plus a few DVDs of the same data to be kept at another address, just in case. Years ago there was an advertising campaign run by one of the magnetic media producers (disks, tapes etc). The message was, "There are two kinds of data: that which is on your hard disk and that which has been backed up, there is no other in-between alternative."
Now back to restructuring my folders . . . .
Reply by Alex W.
A question to the Dropbox users: Do multiple versions (revisions) of a file count (add up) against your storage limit or does a file only count once?
I couldn't find that out from their website.
I've also been interested in Dropbox for a while.
However, if multiple revisions of a file add up against the storage quota, I would exceed the 2 GB limit fairly quickly.
I couldn't find that out from their website.
I've also been interested in Dropbox for a while.
However, if multiple revisions of a file add up against the storage quota, I would exceed the 2 GB limit fairly quickly.
Reply by RogerJ
I guess it would be the total size of all your files, old, new and revised, at any one time.
Reply by Alex W.
Hmm... any comments from actual Dropbox users?
BTW, I just found a post with the information that Dropbox will now only keep 30 days of revision history, unless you pay.
http://www.allyourspace.com/dropbox-undo-history-iphone-app-and-lan-sync/
Really liked this piece of marketing speak: The change is said to have been made because "[f]or many people this [i.e., unlimited undo history] creates clutter, and it also wastes space". And not, becauses it costs the Dropbox guys server space and not to force people to upgrade to a paid account, of course :-)
OTOH, the "wastes space" remark seems to indicate that past versions do indeed count against the account limit.
The post I quoted above includes another information that might be useful for RogerJ's use case: a new LAN Sync feature that "knows when Dropboxes are on the same network and will automatically exchange files directly between computers instead of downloading them from our servers". To me that sounds interesting if you have a unreliable internet connection.
BTW, I just found a post with the information that Dropbox will now only keep 30 days of revision history, unless you pay.
http://www.allyourspace.com/dropbox-undo-history-iphone-app-and-lan-sync/
Really liked this piece of marketing speak: The change is said to have been made because "[f]or many people this [i.e., unlimited undo history] creates clutter, and it also wastes space". And not, becauses it costs the Dropbox guys server space and not to force people to upgrade to a paid account, of course :-)
OTOH, the "wastes space" remark seems to indicate that past versions do indeed count against the account limit.
The post I quoted above includes another information that might be useful for RogerJ's use case: a new LAN Sync feature that "knows when Dropboxes are on the same network and will automatically exchange files directly between computers instead of downloading them from our servers". To me that sounds interesting if you have a unreliable internet connection.
Reply by RogerJ
Thanks Alex W,
"knows when Dropboxes are on the same network" I assume that one has one login ID, password etc and the Dropbox application sees the Dropbox folder on each computer.
Does that mean Dropbox uses mac addresses or similar?
Anyone tried just synchronising with a USB cable, BlueTooth or wifi? That may be better for me ie independent of the Internet, maybe with SynchToy or similar? That way I could just use DropBox for approved colleagues to pick and deposit files as required.
"knows when Dropboxes are on the same network" I assume that one has one login ID, password etc and the Dropbox application sees the Dropbox folder on each computer.
Does that mean Dropbox uses mac addresses or similar?
Anyone tried just synchronising with a USB cable, BlueTooth or wifi? That may be better for me ie independent of the Internet, maybe with SynchToy or similar? That way I could just use DropBox for approved colleagues to pick and deposit files as required.
Reply by mcogilvie
Dropbox works very well. 2 Gig is a lot of data. Just try it, and don't overthink the decision.
Reply by Alex W.
From these discussions in the Dropbox forum I get the impression that pure local LAN sync doesn't work (yet).
http://forums.dropbox.com/topic.php?id=17574
http://forums.dropbox.com/topic.php?id=17408
Regarding the inner workings of the Dropbox system, I have no idea.
http://forums.dropbox.com/topic.php?id=17574
http://forums.dropbox.com/topic.php?id=17408
Regarding the inner workings of the Dropbox system, I have no idea.
Reply by Mike
Roger,
I see you are trying DropBox. I got a bump of 250mb due to your accepting my referral. Thanks much. I'm sure you will find it useful, even if not the perfect answer.
I see you are trying DropBox. I got a bump of 250mb due to your accepting my referral. Thanks much. I'm sure you will find it useful, even if not the perfect answer.
Reply by RogerJ
Mike,
Pleasure, however I am not diving into it straight away, I've been looking at the forum re Outlook.PST syncing.
I think I have to complete my main computer's fold restructuring first, then decide which folders to drop into DropBox. My Outlook.PST file also needs to be rationalised.
Thanks, everyone, for comments, feedback etc, more from me later.
Pleasure, however I am not diving into it straight away, I've been looking at the forum re Outlook.PST syncing.
I think I have to complete my main computer's fold restructuring first, then decide which folders to drop into DropBox. My Outlook.PST file also needs to be rationalised.
Thanks, everyone, for comments, feedback etc, more from me later.
Reply by Roger J
I came across this article last night re synchronisation using Microsoft's Windows Live free service:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/11/technology/personaltech/11pogue-email.html?8cir&emc=cira1
This sentence caught my attention:
"Microsoft recommends that you don't sync your Outlook mail stash, because it's an enormous file that's constantly changing."
This seems to reflect Brian's posting re Outlook.
In thinking abut what I want to do, I think I will indeed exclude Outlook. This will be ok because my Smartphone will have updated calendar, addresses etc via syncing with Windows Mobile, but I do not sync emails.
All my inbound emails to my main account are copied to a couple of Google Mail addresses, so I can see what is urgent when away from my main desk Toshiba. And I always have the option of taking that Toshiba with me, but won't because my new Toshiba notebook is so much easier to tote around.
Before a long flight or lengthy meeting,I can always copy the main Outlook.PST file across.
Now to set up syncing via DropBox and include OneNote along with key data folders eg assignment stuff.
:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/11/technology/personaltech/11pogue-email.html?8cir&emc=cira1
This sentence caught my attention:
"Microsoft recommends that you don't sync your Outlook mail stash, because it's an enormous file that's constantly changing."
This seems to reflect Brian's posting re Outlook.
In thinking abut what I want to do, I think I will indeed exclude Outlook. This will be ok because my Smartphone will have updated calendar, addresses etc via syncing with Windows Mobile, but I do not sync emails.
All my inbound emails to my main account are copied to a couple of Google Mail addresses, so I can see what is urgent when away from my main desk Toshiba. And I always have the option of taking that Toshiba with me, but won't because my new Toshiba notebook is so much easier to tote around.
Before a long flight or lengthy meeting,I can always copy the main Outlook.PST file across.
Now to set up syncing via DropBox and include OneNote along with key data folders eg assignment stuff.
:
Reply by Chris Cooper
I'm a happy user of Dropbox, but there's one shortcoming that may make me look for an alternative.
Dropbox syncs files that are kept in a specified folder (called My Dropbox in my system). This is a pain for me, because I have a particular folder that I want to sync, but have to keep elsewhere, where it can be accessed by a particular application.
Dropbox promises to implement a feature called Watch Any Folder that will enable syncing of a folder located anywhere. But they've been promising a long time. Other sync apps, such as SugarSync, apparently have this feature.
Chris
Dropbox syncs files that are kept in a specified folder (called My Dropbox in my system). This is a pain for me, because I have a particular folder that I want to sync, but have to keep elsewhere, where it can be accessed by a particular application.
Dropbox promises to implement a feature called Watch Any Folder that will enable syncing of a folder located anywhere. But they've been promising a long time. Other sync apps, such as SugarSync, apparently have this feature.
Chris
Reply by Ben
Chris:
A workaround is the use of junction points in Windows and symbolic links in Linux and Mac OS. It's kind of like a shortcut, but at a deeper level in the file system. For applications, it looks like the same folder exists in two places, but the space is only used once on the hard drive.
So if were on Windows and had your dropbox folder in C:\Users\Username\My Dropbox, you could create for example junctions points
from C:\Users\Username\My Dropbox\Photos to C:\Users\Username\Pictures\
or
from C:\Users\Username\My Dropbox\Projects to D:\Projects.
Then, everything you put in C:\Users\Username\Pictures\ or D:\Projects gets synced by Dropbox.
A workaround is the use of junction points in Windows and symbolic links in Linux and Mac OS. It's kind of like a shortcut, but at a deeper level in the file system. For applications, it looks like the same folder exists in two places, but the space is only used once on the hard drive.
So if were on Windows and had your dropbox folder in C:\Users\Username\My Dropbox, you could create for example junctions points
from C:\Users\Username\My Dropbox\Photos to C:\Users\Username\Pictures\
or
from C:\Users\Username\My Dropbox\Projects to D:\Projects.
Then, everything you put in C:\Users\Username\Pictures\ or D:\Projects gets synced by Dropbox.
Reply by Ben
Here's a detailed explanation: http://wiki.dropbox.com/TipsAndTricks/SyncOtherFolders
Reply by Ben
The easiest way, if you're on windows, is probably this one: http://wiki.dropbox.com/DropboxAddons/DropboxFolderSync
Reply by Chris Cooper
Wow, thanks for all those, Ben!
As it happens, this has become academic for me - at least for the moment - because I found that I was wrong and that I can in fact point the other application at a subfolder in the Dropbox folder.
But I can imagine that I'll be needing those other refs of yours some time.
Thanks again.
Chris
As it happens, this has become academic for me - at least for the moment - because I found that I was wrong and that I can in fact point the other application at a subfolder in the Dropbox folder.
But I can imagine that I'll be needing those other refs of yours some time.
Thanks again.
Chris