Poll
Original Post
Mark, I wonder if you might be willing to set up a poll that would gauge the use of the current systems, just to see what everyone is using? It would be an interesting experiment, and I'm not sure that just number of threads with questions about systems alone provides a solid answer.
Reply by Andreas Hofmann
David Drake started a poll some time ago just using the forum: http://www.markforster.net/forum/post/1013508
To make things more comfortable and spare Mark the trouble, we could just use one of the many free online survey tools out there. For example, I just created this one: http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/GHX27HY
To make things more comfortable and spare Mark the trouble, we could just use one of the many free online survey tools out there. For example, I just created this one: http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/GHX27HY
Reply by Mike
Hey Andreas,
Good to see you again. Ever the useful bloke to have hanging around with simple and quick answers. Thanks so much.
Good to see you again. Ever the useful bloke to have hanging around with simple and quick answers. Thanks so much.
Reply by Mark Forster
Andreas:
I've filled in my answers. Is there any way of seeing the totals?
Squarespace does have a polling facility, though I've never tried to use it. I'll see if it would be suitable.
I've filled in my answers. Is there any way of seeing the totals?
Squarespace does have a polling facility, though I've never tried to use it. I'll see if it would be suitable.
Reply by Andreas Hofmann
Mark:
Ah, that seems to be the catch with SurveyMonkey, I can see the results just fine, but others can't. I can post the results here or create a website to display them.
Here's what's in so far:
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using?
DIT 14.3%
AF1 14.3%
AF2 14.3%
AF3 0.0%
AF4 14.3%
DWM 28.6%
None 14.3%
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device?
Pen and paper works best for me. 71.4%
Digital for me, please. 14.3%
I actually use a combination of both. 14.3%
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them?
I follow the rules to the letter. 71.4%
I made some adjustments. 28.6%
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past?
DIT 57.1%
AF1 100.0%
AF2 85.7%
AF3 71.4%
AF4 100.0%
DWM 42.9%
Ah, that seems to be the catch with SurveyMonkey, I can see the results just fine, but others can't. I can post the results here or create a website to display them.
Here's what's in so far:
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using?
DIT 14.3%
AF1 14.3%
AF2 14.3%
AF3 0.0%
AF4 14.3%
DWM 28.6%
None 14.3%
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device?
Pen and paper works best for me. 71.4%
Digital for me, please. 14.3%
I actually use a combination of both. 14.3%
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them?
I follow the rules to the letter. 71.4%
I made some adjustments. 28.6%
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past?
DIT 57.1%
AF1 100.0%
AF2 85.7%
AF3 71.4%
AF4 100.0%
DWM 42.9%
Reply by Mike
And I'm guessing 6 respondents represented there...
Reply by Mark Forster
Seven surely?
Reply by Andreas Hofmann
Yes, it was seven, sorry. Current stats (all but the first question are optional, so the totals may vary for these questions):
Total Started Survey: 13
Total Completed Survey: 13 (100%)
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using?
DIT 15.4% 2
AF1 7.7% 1
AF2 15.4% 2
AF3 0.0% 0
AF4 15.4% 2
DWM 38.5% 5
None 15.4% 2
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device?
Pen and paper works best for me. 61.5% 8
Digital for me, please. 30.8% 4
I actually use a combination of both. 7.7% 1
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them?
I follow the rules to the letter. 66.7% 8
I made some adjustments. 33.3% 4
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past?
DIT 53.8% 7
AF1 100.0% 13
AF2 84.6% 11
AF3 69.2% 9
AF4 92.3% 12
DWM 53.8% 7
Total Started Survey: 13
Total Completed Survey: 13 (100%)
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using?
DIT 15.4% 2
AF1 7.7% 1
AF2 15.4% 2
AF3 0.0% 0
AF4 15.4% 2
DWM 38.5% 5
None 15.4% 2
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device?
Pen and paper works best for me. 61.5% 8
Digital for me, please. 30.8% 4
I actually use a combination of both. 7.7% 1
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them?
I follow the rules to the letter. 66.7% 8
I made some adjustments. 33.3% 4
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past?
DIT 53.8% 7
AF1 100.0% 13
AF2 84.6% 11
AF3 69.2% 9
AF4 92.3% 12
DWM 53.8% 7
Reply by Jacqueline
Andreas, I wish you had some kind of selection of "follow principles of multiple systems, but not the letter" - because I kind of do a form of DIT / AF1 / DWM - but on a weekly basis though.
It gives me a little more breathing room to have more time for consideration if this is something I should be doing. I write in pencil so that I can just erase as I only have 30ish lines on my moleskine weekly daytimer. It also keeps the list short (due to chunking / grouping tasks vs. listing every little thing) as I have this overwhelm problem if I have a big list.
I also don't operate it as a "will do" but dismiss a la AF1. Also don't cross it off and rewrite if I work on one of the projects a little bit during the week but don't finish it, but leave it on and just put a check mark beside it if I touched it that week. No checkmark, no carry forward. (Well, most of the time.) ;-)
It gives me a little more breathing room to have more time for consideration if this is something I should be doing. I write in pencil so that I can just erase as I only have 30ish lines on my moleskine weekly daytimer. It also keeps the list short (due to chunking / grouping tasks vs. listing every little thing) as I have this overwhelm problem if I have a big list.
I also don't operate it as a "will do" but dismiss a la AF1. Also don't cross it off and rewrite if I work on one of the projects a little bit during the week but don't finish it, but leave it on and just put a check mark beside it if I touched it that week. No checkmark, no carry forward. (Well, most of the time.) ;-)
Reply by Andreas Hofmann
Jaqueline:
For that purpose I allowed multiple choices on the first question, so you can check DIT, AF1 and DWM. And then on question 3 select "I made some adjustments" (optionally describing them briefly). That should capture it, shouldn't it?
For that purpose I allowed multiple choices on the first question, so you can check DIT, AF1 and DWM. And then on question 3 select "I made some adjustments" (optionally describing them briefly). That should capture it, shouldn't it?
Reply by Andreas Hofmann
Sorry, the c in your name got lost, my bad.
Reply by Andreas Hofmann
Total Started Survey: 27
Total Completed Survey: 27 (100%)
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using? (answered 27/skipped 0)
DIT 14.8% 4
AF1 11.1% 3
AF2 7.4% 2
AF3 0.0% 0
AF4 18.5% 5
DWM 48.1% 13
None 7.4% 2
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device? (answered 27/skipped 0)
Pen and paper works best for me. 55.6% 15
Digital for me, please. 37.0% 10
I actually use a combination of both. 7.4% 2
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them? (answered 25/skipped 2)
I follow the rules to the letter. 68.0% 17
I made some adjustments. 32.0% 8
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past? (answered 27/skipped 0)
DIT 48.1% 13
AF1 96.3% 26
AF2 88.9% 24
AF3 66.7% 18
AF4 77.8% 21
DWM 66.7% 18
Total Completed Survey: 27 (100%)
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using? (answered 27/skipped 0)
DIT 14.8% 4
AF1 11.1% 3
AF2 7.4% 2
AF3 0.0% 0
AF4 18.5% 5
DWM 48.1% 13
None 7.4% 2
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device? (answered 27/skipped 0)
Pen and paper works best for me. 55.6% 15
Digital for me, please. 37.0% 10
I actually use a combination of both. 7.4% 2
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them? (answered 25/skipped 2)
I follow the rules to the letter. 68.0% 17
I made some adjustments. 32.0% 8
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past? (answered 27/skipped 0)
DIT 48.1% 13
AF1 96.3% 26
AF2 88.9% 24
AF3 66.7% 18
AF4 77.8% 21
DWM 66.7% 18
Reply by Jacqueline
Awesome! Sorry, thought the percentages had to add. :-) I'm in the slow group for this class I guess.
Good to see you again Andreas!
Good to see you again Andreas!
Reply by RogerJ
Mark: this is good stuff for you, and also for us,
Could you not talk to Andreas "Helping Hand" Hofmann to be able to post the updated results on a side bar, maybe on the left where the comments have been noted?
Now to take the survey - thanks, Andreas.
Could you not talk to Andreas "Helping Hand" Hofmann to be able to post the updated results on a side bar, maybe on the left where the comments have been noted?
Now to take the survey - thanks, Andreas.
Reply by TK
I concur with RogerJ's sentiments-TK
Reply by nuntym
Awesome idea Andreas!
I placed my vote >.<
I placed my vote >.<
Reply by moises
I just voted. Thanks.
Reply by Andreas Hofmann
Total Started Survey: 45
Total Completed Survey: 45 (100%)
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using?
(answered 45/skipped 0)
DIT 15.6% 7
AF1 11.1% 5
AF2 4.4% 2
AF3 0.0% 0
AF4 24.4% 11
DWM 51.1% 23
None 6.7% 3
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device?
(answered 45/skipped 0)
Pen and paper works best for me. 62.2% 28
Digital for me, please. 26.7% 12
I actually use a combination of both. 11.1% 5
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them?
(answered 43/skipped 2)
I follow the rules to the letter. 58.1% 25
Show repliesI made some adjustments. 41.9% 18
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past?
(answered 44/skipped 1)
DIT 40.9% 18
AF1 95.5% 42
AF2 88.6% 39
AF3 63.6% 28
AF4 75.0% 33
DWM 65.9% 29
Total Completed Survey: 45 (100%)
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using?
(answered 45/skipped 0)
DIT 15.6% 7
AF1 11.1% 5
AF2 4.4% 2
AF3 0.0% 0
AF4 24.4% 11
DWM 51.1% 23
None 6.7% 3
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device?
(answered 45/skipped 0)
Pen and paper works best for me. 62.2% 28
Digital for me, please. 26.7% 12
I actually use a combination of both. 11.1% 5
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them?
(answered 43/skipped 2)
I follow the rules to the letter. 58.1% 25
Show repliesI made some adjustments. 41.9% 18
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past?
(answered 44/skipped 1)
DIT 40.9% 18
AF1 95.5% 42
AF2 88.6% 39
AF3 63.6% 28
AF4 75.0% 33
DWM 65.9% 29
Reply by David Drake
Hi Andreas,
I took the poll -- sorry I am so late. I am relaxed and quite productive these days with Autofocus 1 in a spiral-bound notebook.
-David
I took the poll -- sorry I am so late. I am relaxed and quite productive these days with Autofocus 1 in a spiral-bound notebook.
-David
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Interesting the diminishing numbers in question 4, and the contrast with question 1's results. Almost everybody tried AF1, AF2, but few still use those. Only 66% tried DWM, but 51% are still using it. Which means 75% of the people who tried DWM consider it the most effective (or else are simply being sheep following the latest trend :-) but 35% of the audience never even tried it.
Reply by Mark Forster
Alan:
Good points. And they probably indicate that it's not a good idea to judge a method until you've tried it. I'm also interested that the proportion of people who use paper and pen only is much greater than the total of the other two choices.
The results of the test also don't seem to me to reflect the same preferences as the posts on this forum, which gave me at least the impression that the majority had tried DWM and didn't like it much, except in its electronic form. I have no intention of going back and counting past posts to see if my impression was correct!
Good points. And they probably indicate that it's not a good idea to judge a method until you've tried it. I'm also interested that the proportion of people who use paper and pen only is much greater than the total of the other two choices.
The results of the test also don't seem to me to reflect the same preferences as the posts on this forum, which gave me at least the impression that the majority had tried DWM and didn't like it much, except in its electronic form. I have no intention of going back and counting past posts to see if my impression was correct!
Reply by RogerJ
Mark,
May I be the "proxy" user on behalf of others to remove the need to go back and reread the posts?
I too thought DWM was more suited to digital and tried it that way. However, since late March, I have been 100% paper and pen and like it, to the extent I have largely forgotten some of the features and advantages of AF1 - AF4! Is there a table somewhere showing AF1 vs AF2 etc to AF4, or maybe AFn>
Having initially said I was NOT looking forward to your current work-in-progress, I am more receptive to seeing it now. Until then, DWM for me.
May I be the "proxy" user on behalf of others to remove the need to go back and reread the posts?
I too thought DWM was more suited to digital and tried it that way. However, since late March, I have been 100% paper and pen and like it, to the extent I have largely forgotten some of the features and advantages of AF1 - AF4! Is there a table somewhere showing AF1 vs AF2 etc to AF4, or maybe AFn>
Having initially said I was NOT looking forward to your current work-in-progress, I am more receptive to seeing it now. Until then, DWM for me.
Reply by Laurence
Mark:
Yes, the results are very interesting, with most people using DWM, and rarely posting on the forum, which suggests they are contented. For myself, I find using software makes all the difference, but obviously most people are getting by well enough with paper.
I experimented for a little while with scanning till a task stands out, and then scanning further till one stands out more. This seemed to select tasks better, but it made the system feel more complex, so I went back to the original way, which feels better.
Yes, the results are very interesting, with most people using DWM, and rarely posting on the forum, which suggests they are contented. For myself, I find using software makes all the difference, but obviously most people are getting by well enough with paper.
I experimented for a little while with scanning till a task stands out, and then scanning further till one stands out more. This seemed to select tasks better, but it made the system feel more complex, so I went back to the original way, which feels better.
Reply by Lenore
Alan,
i thought I'd delurk to make one personal observation about my experience with question 4. At least in my case, when I read the question, I mistakenly answered no because I currently use DWM and the wording said "in the past." Once I submitted with a fast-twitch mouse click, it was too late to go back and change my answer. So I'm one of the 35 percent who seems not to have used DWM.
i thought I'd delurk to make one personal observation about my experience with question 4. At least in my case, when I read the question, I mistakenly answered no because I currently use DWM and the wording said "in the past." Once I submitted with a fast-twitch mouse click, it was too late to go back and change my answer. So I'm one of the 35 percent who seems not to have used DWM.
Reply by Andreas Hofmann
Total Started Survey: 64
Total Completed Survey: 64 (100%)
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using?
(answered 64/skipped 0)
DIT 14.1% 9
AF1 10.9% 7
AF2 3.1% 2
AF3 3.1% 2
AF4 26.6% 17
DWM 45.3% 29
None 9.4% 6
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device?
(answered 64/skipped 0)
Pen and paper works best for me. 59.4% 38
Digital for me, please. 29.7% 19
I actually use a combination of both. 10.9% 7
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them?
(answered 61/skipped 3)
I follow the rules to the letter. 59.0% 36
I made some adjustments. 41.0% 25
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past?
(answered 62/skipped 2)
DIT 43.5% 27
AF1 95.2% 59
AF2 83.9% 52
AF3 61.3% 38
AF4 74.2% 46
DWM 59.7% 37
Total Completed Survey: 64 (100%)
1. Which of Mark Forster's systems are you currently using?
(answered 64/skipped 0)
DIT 14.1% 9
AF1 10.9% 7
AF2 3.1% 2
AF3 3.1% 2
AF4 26.6% 17
DWM 45.3% 29
None 9.4% 6
2. Do you use pen and paper or any form of electronic device?
(answered 64/skipped 0)
Pen and paper works best for me. 59.4% 38
Digital for me, please. 29.7% 19
I actually use a combination of both. 10.9% 7
3. Do you follow the rules exactly or have you modified them?
(answered 61/skipped 3)
I follow the rules to the letter. 59.0% 36
I made some adjustments. 41.0% 25
4. Which of Mark's systems have you tried in the past?
(answered 62/skipped 2)
DIT 43.5% 27
AF1 95.2% 59
AF2 83.9% 52
AF3 61.3% 38
AF4 74.2% 46
DWM 59.7% 37
Reply by Andreas Hofmann
Lenore:
Sorry about the wording. We could start collecting ideas for improving upon this poll and start a new one once every month or every three months or something.
Sorry about the wording. We could start collecting ideas for improving upon this poll and start a new one once every month or every three months or something.
Reply by Mike
Andreas,
Candidate changes:
#2. If pen and paper, what size notebook to you find works best for you? (Why?)
If digital, what system do you find most helpful. (Why?)
#4. Which of Mark's systems have you used and for how long?
#3. What techniques OUTSIDE of Mark's systems (not covered by them) do you use:
- Set Goals and do a Periodic Review
- Calendar Appointments
- Schedule Blocks of time for bigger projects
- Pomadoro
- Keep Project List
- Keep tickler file
- (other)
Note: where you have open ended questions it might be useful to collect the information you get and make them choices in subsequent polls.
#x. Have you quantified how much the system you are using has improved your productivity? (If Yes: how much (in percent)?
Note: That last needs work to be useful. I'd expect that Mark would want to craft that one to make it useful to him.
#y. What has been the greatest impact of the system on your productivity or way of working?
Candidate changes:
#2. If pen and paper, what size notebook to you find works best for you? (Why?)
If digital, what system do you find most helpful. (Why?)
#4. Which of Mark's systems have you used and for how long?
#3. What techniques OUTSIDE of Mark's systems (not covered by them) do you use:
- Set Goals and do a Periodic Review
- Calendar Appointments
- Schedule Blocks of time for bigger projects
- Pomadoro
- Keep Project List
- Keep tickler file
- (other)
Note: where you have open ended questions it might be useful to collect the information you get and make them choices in subsequent polls.
#x. Have you quantified how much the system you are using has improved your productivity? (If Yes: how much (in percent)?
Note: That last needs work to be useful. I'd expect that Mark would want to craft that one to make it useful to him.
#y. What has been the greatest impact of the system on your productivity or way of working?
Reply by Seraphim
Based on Andreas Hoffman's latest post, here are the "retention rates" for Mark's systems (% of people who started the system who are still using it):
DIT 33%
AF1 12%
AF2 4%
AF3 5%
AF4 37%
DWM 78%
DIT 33%
AF1 12%
AF2 4%
AF3 5%
AF4 37%
DWM 78%
Reply by Seraphim
Sorry Andreas for butchering your last name...
Reply by Mike
Seraphim,
Very useful way to look at it. I wonder if there is a away to factor in how long the systems have been around. IOW, the number for DWM is less impressive to me because it is very new and people have not had enough time for frustration to build.
Another factor is that some of us have switched BACK to a previous system. I'm not sure how you'd express that.
Finally, it might be interesting to Mark to know how many people have dropped ALL of his systems ... probably a small number, but there are some.
Very useful way to look at it. I wonder if there is a away to factor in how long the systems have been around. IOW, the number for DWM is less impressive to me because it is very new and people have not had enough time for frustration to build.
Another factor is that some of us have switched BACK to a previous system. I'm not sure how you'd express that.
Finally, it might be interesting to Mark to know how many people have dropped ALL of his systems ... probably a small number, but there are some.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Also, DWM is the latest, and I think people use that because "it's new, so it must be better", and at some level most of these systems work it's just a question of persistence and community support.
Reply by moises
Alan,
There seems to be a Primacy-Recency effect here. There is a U-shaped curve.
There seems to be a Primacy-Recency effect here. There is a U-shaped curve.
Reply by Alex W.
Another way to look at it:
DIT and DWM, both diary-based, could be regarded as more structured approaches than AF 1-4, which in turn are simple list-based systems.
Based on the latest numbers (May 4), here are the "retention rates" for DIT and DWM on one side and all AFs combined on the other:
DIT/DWM: 45.3% (38 out of 64)
AF 1-4: 14.4% (28 out of 195)
This seems to show a strong preference for a more structured approach by many people, which is somewhat in contrast with many posts in the forum, where there seems to be a preference for AF1/4.
OTOH, the validity of this conclusion is questionable, as anyone who didn't stick to DIT, and went through all systems, has been through all of the AFs and arrived at DWM for the moment. So constant switchers will dilute the AF numbers, and strengthen those for DWM.
In addition, the May 4 numbers show that the majority *has* been through all of the AFs.
Regarding DIT: Given that DIT has been around the longest and wasn't made available on this website only, but also distributed by the book, it should be the system that has been tried by many more people than the others. Most DIT users, whether satisfied with the system and still using it or not, will not have taken the poll. Most will not even know it. Someone who tried DIT a long time ago and abandoned it, might not be visiting this website anymore.
So this "retention rate" thing is probably moot.
BTW: It would be nice if the additional comments (personal tweaks etc.) from the poll could be made available als well.
Just my 2p, and now back to re-starting DWM...
DIT and DWM, both diary-based, could be regarded as more structured approaches than AF 1-4, which in turn are simple list-based systems.
Based on the latest numbers (May 4), here are the "retention rates" for DIT and DWM on one side and all AFs combined on the other:
DIT/DWM: 45.3% (38 out of 64)
AF 1-4: 14.4% (28 out of 195)
This seems to show a strong preference for a more structured approach by many people, which is somewhat in contrast with many posts in the forum, where there seems to be a preference for AF1/4.
OTOH, the validity of this conclusion is questionable, as anyone who didn't stick to DIT, and went through all systems, has been through all of the AFs and arrived at DWM for the moment. So constant switchers will dilute the AF numbers, and strengthen those for DWM.
In addition, the May 4 numbers show that the majority *has* been through all of the AFs.
Regarding DIT: Given that DIT has been around the longest and wasn't made available on this website only, but also distributed by the book, it should be the system that has been tried by many more people than the others. Most DIT users, whether satisfied with the system and still using it or not, will not have taken the poll. Most will not even know it. Someone who tried DIT a long time ago and abandoned it, might not be visiting this website anymore.
So this "retention rate" thing is probably moot.
BTW: It would be nice if the additional comments (personal tweaks etc.) from the poll could be made available als well.
Just my 2p, and now back to re-starting DWM...
Reply by Alex W.
Oops, just noticed that "by the book" probably means somthing different than what I wanted to say. Should have written "with the book" or "through the book" or something like that.